Nonprofit Strategic Planning: A Step-by-Step Guide for Small Organizations

Picture a common start. The board votes in September for a three-year strategic plan by spring. Nobody says who will write it, what it will cost or when the work will happen. In a small nonprofit, all three questions land on the executive director, in evenings that were already full.

That assignment is workable. Nonprofit strategic planning for a small organization needs a short process, a few clear decisions and a review calendar the board will keep. The seven steps below are sized for that. For the wider picture of mission, programs and long-range choices, start with our guide to nonprofit strategy.

What Is a Nonprofit Strategic Plan?

A nonprofit strategic plan is a short document that records the organization’s choices for the next two to three years: the few goals it will pursue, what it will stop doing, who owns each goal and how progress will be checked. It sits above the annual operating plan and budget, which turn this year’s share into tasks.

A plan that lists each program the organization already runs, with “strengthen” in front of it, is a wish list. One test settles it: could a board member use the plan to turn down a new program? If not, the priorities are still too broad.

Plans are also getting shorter. BoardSource reports a shift away from traditional plans built on three- to five-year horizons, toward flexible frameworks that name priorities and get reviewed regularly.

A business plan does a narrower job: it tests whether one program can pay its way. Our comparison shows how a business plan differs.

What Should a Nonprofit Strategic Plan Include?

A nonprofit strategic plan should include seven parts: the mission and vision, a one-page summary of where the organization stands, no more than three strategic goals, a stop-doing list, one or two measures for each goal, an owner and review date for each goal, and a one-page note on what the plan means for the budget.

• Mission and vision. One paragraph each, rewritten only if they no longer describe the work.
• Situation summary. One page on finances, program results and what staff, board members, funders and the people you serve told you.
• Three strategic goals at most. Each names a result and a year.
• Stop-doing list. Three to five programs, events or habits to end or shrink so the goals have room.
• Measures. One or two per goal, from data you already collect.
• Owners and a review calendar. A name beside each goal and four review dates on the board calendar.
• Budget implication. What each goal costs, what stopping saves and where new money must come from.

A sample line from a fictional food bank shows the shape: “Goal 2, year one: close the Tuesday pantry shift and move its volunteers to Saturday distribution.” The line says what stops as well as what grows.

Expect the stop-doing list to draw the most debate at the board table. Keep it anyway. Without it, the three goals compete for staff time with everything already running.

What Are the Nonprofit Strategic Planning Steps?

Nonprofit strategic planning runs in seven steps: decide who holds the pen, gather a short picture of where you stand, revisit the mission and vision, choose a planning approach that fits your size, pick three goals and a stop-doing list, assign owners and measures, then approve the plan and book the first review.

1. Decide who holds the pen

Settle this in week one: the executive director drafts, a planning group of two or three board members and one or two staff reacts, and the full board approves. BoardSource describes the board’s role as setting direction, providing input and approving the plan. Name the problem the plan should solve, too. In its matching work, CNPC often sees boards ask for “a plan by spring” before anyone has said what is going wrong.

2. Gather a short picture of where you stand

Pull three years of financials and last year’s program numbers, then hold five to eight short conversations with staff, board members, a funder and people you serve, asking each what the organization does well and where it falls short. Then run a SWOT analysis (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats) that ends in decisions: beside each threat, write what you would do about it.

3. Revisit the mission and vision

Read both statements aloud at a board meeting and ask whether they still describe the work. If they do, keep them. A full rewrite is its own project, for when the purpose has changed.

4. Choose an approach that fits your size

A classic three-year plan suits steady funding. When funding or community needs shift fast, plan on a shorter horizon and adjust as you learn. In the Stanford Social Innovation Review, Dana O’Donovan and Noah Rimland Flower call this “setting a direction and testing to it.”

5. Pick three goals and write the stop-doing list

This step turns hopes into a strategy. In one half-day session with the board and senior staff, choose no more than three goals, then list what the organization will stop or shrink to pay for them. If you want a thinking partner while you choose, a volunteer coach can work through it with you.

Every program already running has a constituency at the board table. A plan that names nothing to stop has quietly kept all of them.

6. Assign owners, measures and a review calendar

Give each goal one owner, one or two measures and a first-year target. For the fictional food bank, the operations manager owns the Saturday goal and reports households served each Saturday against the year-one target. Set four quarterly reviews of 45 minutes each. At every review, owners report progress, problems and what they need.

7. Approve, share and book the first review

Bring the draft to the full board for a vote, and put all four quarterly review dates on the board calendar in the same motion. A review booked after the vote is easy to skip. Within a month, share a two-page version with staff and funders.

The hours below assume a board of 7 to 12, no planning staff and an executive director who drafts. They are planning estimates for scheduling, not survey data.

How Long Does Strategic Planning Take?

For a small nonprofit running the process itself, the schedule in this guide spans 8 to 12 weeks, and the estimates above come to about 35 hours of the executive director’s time, roughly three hours a week. A retreat-based version packs steps 3 to 5 into one or two days but adds preparation before it.

Stretching the process past a season costs momentum: board members rotate off and the situation summary goes stale. When time is short, cut in this order: use last year’s program numbers instead of new data, hold five conversations instead of eight, and fold the mission review into the goals session. Keep the stop-doing list and the review calendar. Those two parts decide whether anyone uses the plan.

Why Do Nonprofit Strategic Plans Stall?

The risky stretch for a nonprofit strategic plan is months 4 to 18, after the energy of approval fades. Goal owners leave or get busy, the board stops asking about progress, and daily operations take the hours the plan needed. A standing quarterly review gives each of those problems a date on which it has to surface.

CNPC’s intake data points the same way. Across 152 applications for coaching, 30 (20%) name strategic planning as the need, and those leaders describe wanting to implement plans rather than shelve them.

At the second quarterly review, check for three signs of a stalled plan: nobody has opened it since the vote, a goal has no owner reporting, and items from the stop-doing list have quietly come back. If you see any of them, restart without starting over: cut one goal, reassign the owners and book the next review before the meeting ends. Protecting strategic time from daily operations covers the weekly habits that keep hours open for plan work.

A review date booked before the vote is the cheapest insurance a strategic plan can buy.

A plan without accountability is a wish list. A coach gives the executive director a thinking partner with no organizational agenda and a fixed time to decide what to cut when a goal slips. Coaching does not write the plan or settle a split board. More on that role: how coaching supports the planning process.

Do You Need a Consultant for a Strategic Plan?

A small nonprofit with a willing board can write its own strategic plan with the steps above. A consultant earns the fee when the plan involves a merger or restructuring, new research on community needs, or a board split deep enough that nobody inside can run the meeting. A facilitator for one retreat sits in between.

A facilitator runs the retreat and leaves the drafting to you.

CNPC coaches leaders through planning and does not write plans, facilitate retreats or consult. When an applicant’s problem needs expertise we do not offer, our matching process says so. Our comparison of when a consultant fits better than a coach sets out how to decide.

Where Should You Start This Week?

Start with one 45-minute conversation with your board chair and one question: which program would we stop if we had to cut one? Bring the answer to the first planning session. It tells you how ready the board is to make the choices a strategic plan needs.

Plan it yourself with the seven steps above, or plan with a volunteer coach beside you. CNPC’s executive coaching program runs six sessions at $300, $400 or $600 depending on your operating budget, because our coaches donate their time. The coach helps you decide what goes in the plan and follow through on it, and the writing stays with you. Apply Now to be matched with a coach.

Frequently Asked Questions